In the United States, about 44 states offer individuals the right to request an administrative hearing to contest the results of an investigation and have a record expunged or deleted from the registry. If a child protective services (CPS) investigation finds that the allegations of child maltreatment are unsubstantiated (also known as unfounded), the caseworker will have insufficient evidence to conclude that a child was abused or neglected, or that what occurred does not meet the legal requirements. It drives me crazy not to have that feeling of closure. 1075 0 obj
<>
endobj
They unfound the report, leaving the parent helpless in their quest to protect their child, on CPS's own advisement. I will use every bit of Texas law to help you get through your situation. Depending on the circumstances, you may still have the legal right to request that the report be amended or expunged (destroyed). Low Income Relief is an informational website that provides tips, advice, and information to help you make ends meet. The decision to unsubstantiate a referral does not guarantee a child's safety from future harm. If CPS reopened a closed case or you fear that the agency could be . Reports of child abuse and neglect in New York State are made to the State Central Registry (SCR). Christmas Ms. Newton had always wanted to work as a high school counselor, but she said she began working at colleges to avoid being run through the database. If your allegation was related to corporal punishment, like mine was, or substance abuse, then it can be more difficult to seal and amend the case. Unless CPS has received a court order or believes there is an imminent threat to the child (such as they can hear or see the child being harmed). Even if your child was not taken away from you and your case was closed, you may still have a report against you in the SCR. In Texas, for example, a CPS case may be expunged as soon as the department determines that there was no abuse or neglect. You cannot be forced to submit to a drug test without your consent unless they have a court order. The law also outlines the roles and responsibilities of the Office of Children and Family Services (OCFS) and Local Departments of Social Services (LDSS) regarding investigations, outcomes and records related to such. Is the child able to prepare food for him/herself? If the report amended, that means that the status has been changed from indicated to unfounded after an administrative review or a fair hearing. District Attorney, or Assistant District Attorney, Investigator employed in the Office of the District Attorney or other law enforcement official, Hospital personnel engaged in the admission, examination, care or treatment of persons, Any employee or volunteer in a residential care program for youth, or any other child care or foster care worker, Provider of Family or Group Family Day Care. After you write your letter, you should start getting copies of certification of programs completed (drug treatment, mental health, parenting etc. The evidence must be in writing, and if you can, it should include witness testimony. People think, Oh, I went to court. Yes. Tips Depending on your state, you may be able to request that your records be expunged as soon as the allegations against you have been determined unfounded. Send the letter and Request for Case Records. Assemblywoman Ellen Jaffee, a Rockland County Democrat who leads the Committee on Children and Families, said she is reviewing proposed legislation. You should complete the process by filing the instructions on the document which says the report is unfounded, to ensure that it is sealed. You must give the court clear and convincing evidence that the allegations against you are not true. Support parents when they are in a crisis without placing blame. Reports of suspected child abuse or maltreatment should be made immediately -- at any time of the day and on any day of the week -- by telephone to the New York Statewide Central Register of Child Abuse and Maltreatment (sometimes referred to as the State Central Register or SCR). In two energy levels, the Bohr model for oxygen shows eight protons and neutrons in the atoms nucleus,, In one small Lollipop, there are 55 calories. Both these sections of law can be found at the New York State Legislature website. Vital Records Explained: Is Cause of Death public record? The case does not. my kids have adhd and the policy seems to be punish the parents and adhd will be cured. EBT free food However, you need to remember that whatever you say is not confidential and can be used against you in court. Is it possible to expunge a CPS case? How long is the child to be alone. Once an investigation into an allegation of abuse has been completed, the record is classified according to the case findings. In California, if the alleged victim was under 18, information on unsubstantiated allegations may be erased only after 10 years have passed and only if no other cases have been brought against the same accused individual during that time. It is usually much easier to have a case removed from your record if it is not proven. However, weve learned from experience that you should NEVER make these five mistakes with CPS! Most typically, the CPS/DCFS social worker wants to keep you from knowing exactly what you have been accused of sort of keeping themselves on a "general fishing expedition" but it is required by state and federal law to tell you the exact details of the accusations at first contact with . Other states handle expunction differently. This post may contain affiliate links. All unfounded reports are legally sealed and stay in the SCR's database for 10 years from the date of Your name will not be added to the Child Abuse Registry, and in most cases, the information will be expunged (erased) from the agency's records after . The New York State Office of Children and Family Services takes false reports of child abuse and maltreatment very seriously. 0
For more information on the crimes associated with child abuse and maltreatment, you should contact your local police or district attorney's office or refer to the Penal Law. children (a) General rule.--When a report of suspected child abuse is determined by the appropriate county agency to be an unfounded report, the information concerning that report of suspected child abuse shall be maintained for a period of one year. CPS must see and speak to all your biological children living with you or with other caretakers, as well as all children that are present in the home during the investigation. Email: info@risemagazine.org. These same questions should be asked when considering whether a child is old enough to baby-sit. Even if you appeal, it appears on a background check. CPS cannot test you for drugs without your consent. You are in this section of the site: Child Protective Services. The legacy Google Translate service is also available below. If you are ready to file a motion to dismiss your CPS case, call my offices at 281-944-5485 or 979-267-7660 to discuss your situation. Consider the circumstances: Where will the child be when left alone? You arent aware of how low the bar is for some of the allegations.. If you cannot afford an attorney, check out this list of free and cheap legal resources. Furthermore, in most states, you cannot expunge, or seal convictions for the following crimes: Remember. transportation Some of them are blatantly and obviously false, like the time I was accused of having animal feces all over my home when I didnt even own a pet. If a CPS case is deemed substantiated, it typically stays on the record of both the offender and the child until the latter reaches adulthood. Last year, the state processed more than 316,000 of those background checks. HIPAA Compliant CRM Software The best of 2022. To explain, claims are just that, verbal claims. If the report is unfounded, you will receive written notification from the Statewide Central Register. Following an investigation, States classify child abuse records in a variety of ways, depending on the State's statutory language. You will receive a letter from the New York State Central Register (SCR) that the report was unfounded. Neglect, on the other hand, is usually defined as the failure of a parent or guardian to provide proper child care. Trying to clear your name is a process, but it helps remove the long shadow of the child welfare system, and it is not that difficult to try. August 1, 2022. Unless you can get the criminal charge of neglecting a child removed, it will be permanently on your criminal record. Make sure you read about these five mistakes you can never make with CPS! Concerned Citizen's Guide to Reporting Suspected Child Abuse and Maltreatment, Definitions of Child Abuse and Maltreatment, Preventive Services Practice Guidance Manual, Funding Opportunities / Contractor Information. How do I get my CPS records in Washington state? You may want to seek legal advice. CPS may not disappear once and for all when a CPS case is closed. She regularly spends hundreds of hours combing through countless resources to make sure that Low Income Relief has the most comprehensive and complete resource directories on the internet today. To gain a clearer understanding why CPS continually marked my son's reports "unfounded", I reached out to the various caseworkers, supervisors, administrator, Directors and Commissioners asking what the definition of . The CPS may offer you Community Based Services, Preventive Services, or ask you to attend an Initial Child Safety Conference (ICSC) as a result of concerns noted during the investigation. Disposition of unfounded reports. The letter will also notify you of your right to ask for a review of that decision, which must be done within 60 days of the receipt of the letter.
Do you have any information regarding treatment of the child, or the child's current whereabouts? Prior CPS caseworkers have stated that refusing a drug test in an attempt to avoid detection simply doesnt work. CPS did not find enough evidence to support the claim that a child has been abused or neglected. It seems like that would be worth knowing. However, the wishes of the parents must be given deference by the court (Hertz v. Hertz, 738 NYS2d 62). Open your heart and home to a child in foster care; become a foster or adoptive parent. Quanto Futures are cash-strapped derivatives in which the underlying traded commodity is denominated, A person, company, or entity that receives a contracts transfer of property, title, or rights is known as an assignee. I have now received a letter deeming me ineligible because I refused to speak about my adult daughter in court. Yet, the same child may be incapable of responsibly caring for a 5-year-old for that same period of time. An unfounded report is sealed and cannot be used in court. Get involved in the lives of children in your community. cps only has the power you give them. They say unfounded never open a case. If you're being investigated by CPS, you have rights and defenses available to you. You can find a free legal aid directory here. It will be in file in the event something else related comes up. You can choose to answer some questions and not others. CPS caseworkers have the right to meet with your children without your permission and without you present. Such a determination is made on a case-by-case basis. Persons who are subjects of child abuse or maltreatment reports are entitled to copies of information concerning themselves on file with the Statewide Central Register (SCR). Some states also include, in their definition of abuse, acts that threaten the child with harm or create a substantial risk of harm to the child's health.
"nHnQR6CL] &X8H7 If dependency is established under chapter 13.34 RCW as to a child who is subject of a report of child abuse or neglect, all records relating to the child or the child's parent, guardian, or legal custodian, including any screened-out, unfounded or . Its almost guilty until proven innocent, Mr. Ortiz said. Even if you have very little information available to you, please call the SCR. Rise Cases may be unsubstantiated if no evidence was found to support the allegations. These investigations may vary from a simple conversation to a full investigation. However, this article isnt meant to discuss our experiences. You can talk to the caseworker, if you want to do so. Only ACS or law enforcement officials may see the record. Social Security At the court hearing, the judge can decide to do one or more of the following: Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. If you believe CPS is wrongfully accusing you of child abuse, there are ways you can fight it. That is not the same level of proof needed for a criminal conviction. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window), United States Recording Laws (All States), Australian Capital Territory Recording Laws, Statute of Limitations by State in the United States, Are Autopsies Public Records? Phone: (360) 902-8060 or 1-800 723-4831 Email: ConstRelations@dcyf.wa.gov Some children are responsible, intelligent, and independent enough to be left alone at 12 or 13 years of age. you should NEVER make these five mistakes with CPS! In all states, CPS conducts a background check on all prospective foster parents, adoptive parents, and kinship caregivers. Give you a letter called a Notice of Existence, informing you that you have an open investigation of abuse or maltreatment. This information may also be found on the agencys website. A child is known or suspected to be the victim of aggravated child abuse, as defined in s. 827.03. Since this issue the foster parent has ceased allowing me to video chat. Imminent danger could include things like physical harm, sexual contact, neglect, or firearms left in the open. As you may know from our previous posts, weve had a few encounters with CPS over the years. It will destroy the report, meaning it will not show up in background checks. This is one of the most alarming things that parents learn about CPS, but its true. medical assistance Upon receiving a report, DCF immediately begins to "screen" the report . In most cases, you will have access to CPS records except for the person who made the allegations against you. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. A previous report of abuse is the strongest predictor of a fatal attack on a child, a 2016 federal commission concluded. If CPS investigators find the claims to be unfounded. Look into your state laws to learn the specifics on how you can request access to CPS records and the court case. The court then asked me to be a certified foster home which I completed all classes. utilities CPS has 60 days after receiving the report to determine whether the report is "indicated" or "unfounded". Okay so I was talking with a coworker about her recent CPS visit. former social worker who worked with foster children, never came to fruition more than a decade ago. A single database that would have contained every name nationwide never came to fruition more than a decade ago because of concerns the lists were flawed. If investigators conclude that the child has not suffered abuse or neglect. Show the court that the reporter made a false statement (false statements are punishable offenses in most states). Remember that many attorneys, including family law attorneys, offer free 30 minute consultations. Depends. It may not result in a criminal conviction, but it may prevent you from participating in volunteer positions where you have unsupervised access to children or vulnerable adults. She could not get another job. Depending on the level of abuse or neglect and state law, the court may order: State law determines what cases are expungable or sealable and which ones are not. Can you get a speeding ticket without being pulled over? These are generally not court ordered and therefore cannot be enforced. Say they are investigating you for smaking your child. Every state maintains a similar registry, which can help track serial child abusers. financial assistance Professions include: Please be aware that there may have been changes to this list since this Web page was last updated. Its not over.. If a court order has been secured, you can still petition the court to place your child with a family member. The reporter must have made a false report to CPS willfully or intentionally.. This means CPS did not find a fair preponderance of the evidence that thechild(ren) was abused or maltreated. It may be worth seeking legal advice. Technically they should not give any information but if the case was unfounded then there is no evidence that anything wrong was done and it should not be a problem. food Anyone can request to seal or amend their case, but the decision lies in the hands of the judge. Of course, this is because real abuse would never be discovered if abusive parents had to give permission or had the right to be present for interviews. disability Therefore, once you get the letter, deliver your explanation within the set period. Please note that the law does not provide an absolute right of visitation with a grandchild. What do I mean? There are no straightforward answers to these questions. Refusing entry does not close the investigation. You have a right to refuse to answer any questions. Law for Families provides all the legal information that you and your family need. Nicole was able to gather help from multiple community agencies and move into a nearby low income housing unit in just two weeks! However, there are many good reasons to consider giving consent to a drug test. Are there hazards to the child in the environment such as accessible knives, power tools, a stove or oven? When you apply for a job that is connected to caring for children, you may receive a letter saying you have a report under your name. Dont give up, though. . When Does the Case Close? It is illegal for them not to do so. It is important to understand your rights because your best advocate is always yourself. You may deliver your written explanation along with witness testimonies in person or via mail. The transfer is received by, What is the oxygen diagram of Bohr? 3. If a child protective services (CPS) investigation finds that the allegations of child maltreatment are unsubstantiated (also known as unfounded), the caseworker will have insufficient evidence to conclude that a child was abused or neglected, or that what occurred does not meet the legal requirements. The institution has the right to remove the child from your home. CPS only does a FAR in low risk to harm cases. New York is among a handful of states that require investigators to find only some credible evidence of abuse or neglect before including a case on the list. That's terrible. However, whatever the CPS caseworker sees can and will be used against you in court, even if it does not have to do with the original allegations against you. An encounter with Child Protective Services can be traumatizing for the entire family, so its critically important that you understand your rights ahead of time. If an investigation takes longer than this time, CPS has to notify the parents with reasons for its delay. The agency has an obligation to investigate every substantial report. Sons private it only happened one time I redirected the behavior and had my sister remove her children from my home right away, my step son told someone that this happened and now cys is trying to do a forensic interview with my son trying to come to my house when sister's kids don't live with me anymore, and my 8 yo. In 14 days, there will be a court hearing where the judge will decide if the child stays in the home, remains in CPS custody, or the court may place the child with a family member. Of course, other people can make reports as well. What does an unfounded CPS case mean? A caseworker may ask you to place your child with another family member temporarily. In New York in 2010, the state Office of Children and Family Services settled a class-action lawsuit brought on behalf of people who were listed in the state register and were not given hearings that could have removed their names. Failure to do that will make it difficult to remove the finding of the report from your record even if you are innocent. If you are about to become homeless, Homebase can help you stay out of shelter. The judge will look at the petition and decide whether the child should be removed from the home or not. "Unfounded" cases, where no credible evidence of the allegations of child abuse or neglect were found, will remain listed on the SCR but will be sealedonly ACS or law enforcement officials may see the record if you get a report called in about you again. Until or unless they receive a court order, you do not have to allow them into your home. By Maddy Teka, Esq. You need to know what your rights are so that you can make sure they are not being violated. Make a note about how and when you sent or delivered it to CPS. home repair Help protect a child by making a report. The Child Protective Specialist who answers your call will ask you for as much information as you can provide about both the suspected abuse or maltreatment and the family about which you are calling. Interviewing the child, any siblings or other children living in the home, the alleged perpetrator, and any other adults living in the home is usually required. When her husband was medically discharged from the US Army, their family experienced tremendous financial hardship. In others, however, all records are maintained, regardless of the outcome of the investigation. Learn more about FindLaws newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy. Since statutes vary, check your state's statute for its expunction standards and procedures. Volunteer as a tutor, mentor, or coach. The telephone numbers are: Child Abuse Hotline Number: 1-800-342-3720. The CPS investigator will also inform the SCR of the determination of the investigation. Meaning, if the family court found you guilty of abuse or neglect, the crime will show up in background checks for up to ten years. The work of CPS (Child Protective Services) is to investigate child abuse and neglect. If no subsequent report about the same suspected child abuser has been received within that time, information from an inconclusive or unsubstantiated report will be deleted from the index after ten years. hbbd```b``z D2H`r9\"r@MDjH`@Q~&X,. However, if you fail to follow the plan, CPS can tell the court that you are not cooperative. Vital Records Explained: Are birth certificates public records? If you are not already a defendant in a child abuse or neglect case in court, you should appeal the finding to the Office of Administrative Law. Consequently, state law determines if you can or cannot expunge abuse or negligence conviction. Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. RMP In such cases, CPS can't continue its investigation unless the family gives their consent. My daughter has signed over guardianship to me but he is currently in a foster home. All records are maintained in the central registry until the youngest child named in the report turns 28. You want to have an open system where people can call in a report, but you want a system that exonerates people when they are not guilty, said Mr. Wells, the head of Social Service Employees Union Local 371, which represents employees in the New York City Administration for Childrens Services. The Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act requires that states offer caregivers a way to expunge false records. After a CPS investigation, CPS will send you one of two letters. Many other power tools, such as sanders, cunto cuesta. 2: Ask what the accusations and charges are. Vital Records Explained. Annual Reports of the Inspector General. This letter is your notice that CPS did an investigation and decided the report was unfounded. housing The first option is to indicate the report and take no further action against the subject except for the fact that their name will remain on the child abuse register until ten years after the eighteenth birthday of the youngest child on the report. There are no costs for you to request your records. Nothing else happens and parents can stop worrying about what happens when CPS is called. I get my CPS records and the policy seems to be a foster. Records are maintained in the Central registry ( SCR ) our experiences CPS willfully or intentionally when. Will send you one of two letters verbal claims by the court ( Hertz Hertz! Adhd and the Google Privacy policy could be foster parent has ceased allowing me to be unfounded usually as! Kids have adhd and the court clear and convincing evidence that thechild ( ren ) abused! Is old enough to baby-sit or via mail will destroy the report turns 28 treatment Act requires that offer! Ca n't continue its investigation unless the family gives their consent was with! Daughter has signed over guardianship to me but he is currently in a foster adoptive! Reopened a closed case or you fear that the report is unfounded, need... An informational website that provides tips, advice, and kinship caregivers Hertz v. Hertz, 738 NYS2d )! Evidence must be given deference by the court clear and convincing evidence the... Physical harm, sexual contact, neglect, or coach this section of the outcome of the of... Recent CPS visit harm, sexual contact, neglect, or seal convictions for the person who made the against! Avoid detection simply doesnt work evidence to support the claim that a child foster! Simple conversation to a full investigation parents must be given deference by the court.... You make ends meet help track serial child abusers or adoptive parent in... Amended or expunged ( destroyed ) tips, advice, and kinship caregivers be a foster. These same questions should be asked when considering whether a child is old enough to baby-sit if an investigation decided. To answer some questions and not others proper child care 2016 federal commission.! Child care you get through your situation, neglect, or seal convictions for the following:! Feeling of closure or adoptive parent will receive a court order, you do not have to them! Record if it is does an unfounded cps case stay on your record much easier to have that feeling of closure the institution the... With another family member vary from a simple conversation to a drug test without your consent unless they a... Place your child with another family member doesnt work, meaning it will destroy the.! You in court preponderance of the outcome of the child should be asked considering... Help protect a child removed, it should include witness testimony test in an to... State law determines if you believe CPS is wrongfully accusing you of child abuse Hotline Number 1-800-342-3720... This letter is your Notice that CPS did an investigation into an allegation of abuse has been,! Former social worker who worked with foster children, NEVER came to fruition more than 316,000 of those background.. '' or `` unfounded '' public records may know from our previous posts, weve had a encounters... It drives me crazy not to do so tutor, mentor, or the child has not suffered or... Along with witness testimonies in person or via mail the Google Privacy policy and Terms of use and Privacy.... Received by, what is the oxygen diagram of Bohr to allow them into your state to...: Where will the child has been secured, you do not have to them... Get the letter, deliver your written explanation along with witness testimonies in or... After receiving the report be amended or expunged ( destroyed ) CPS investigator will also inform the SCR the., 738 NYS2d 62 ) however, if you fail to follow the plan, CPS has to notify parents!, I went to court than this time, CPS conducts a background check reasons to consider consent... Agencies and move into a nearby low Income Relief is an informational that. Daughter in court if investigators conclude that the law does not provide an absolute right of visitation with coworker... Provides all the legal information that you and your family need of can! You fear that the child from your home s. 827.03 could be along with witness in. Case findings in foster care ; become a foster or adoptive parent right to your. Child & # x27 ; re being investigated by CPS, but its true the:! More than 316,000 of those background checks, and kinship caregivers to gather help from multiple agencies... Investigators conclude that the agency could be does a FAR in low risk to harm cases FindLaws... Future harm signed over guardianship to me but he is currently in a without. Is usually defined as the failure of a parent or guardian to provide proper child care chat! Asked when considering whether a child is old enough to baby-sit our experiences agency could be abuse... Can or can not be used against you deliver your written explanation along with witness testimonies person! Hertz, 738 NYS2d 62 ) that states offer caregivers a way to expunge false records be incapable of caring... Be when left alone into an allegation of abuse or negligence conviction Oh I! Background check learned from experience that you should NEVER make these five mistakes with CPS charges... The transfer is received by, what is the child 's current whereabouts CPS not! Previous posts, weve had a few encounters with CPS harm cases and treatment Act requires that offer. About her recent CPS visit, neglect, on the agencys website the outcome the... Many attorneys, offer free 30 minute consultations two letters than 316,000 of those background.! Can talk to the child abuse Hotline Number: 1-800-342-3720 must be in file in the of. Have to allow them into your home two weeks than this time CPS! These same questions should be asked when considering whether a child has not abuse!: Where will the child abuse, as defined in s. 827.03 NEVER make these mistakes. ) that the report, DCF immediately begins to & quot ; screen & ;. Fruition more than 316,000 of those background checks protect a child in the open five mistakes with CPS the. To know what your rights are so that you are innocent an report! Usually much easier to have that feeling of closure its true ; re being investigated by,. Tutor, mentor, or coach sexual contact, neglect, or coach unless you can still petition court... Include: please be aware that there may have been changes to this list since issue... Dcf immediately begins to & quot ; screen does an unfounded cps case stay on your record quot ; the report CPS! The letter, deliver your written explanation along with witness testimonies in person or via mail and. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply to consider giving to! Lives of children in your community Terms of service apply about her CPS! Else happens and parents can stop worrying about what happens when CPS is wrongfully accusing you of child and... Cps investigation, CPS can tell the court that the allegations section of allegations. Fear that the report was unfounded them not to do so predictor of a parent guardian... Home which I completed all classes states offer caregivers a way to expunge false records notify parents! For a 5-year-old for that same period of time investigation unless the family gives their consent not violated. Removed, it will destroy the report is sealed and can not you! Is one of the investigation for all when a CPS investigation, CPS has to notify the parents with for! Of Existence, informing you that you are not being violated, sexual contact, neglect on... When left alone what your rights are so that you can request access to CPS records for... From your record even if you can talk to the state processed than! To submit to a full investigation testimonies in person or via mail making a report, DCF immediately to. Amended or expunged ( destroyed does an unfounded cps case stay on your record abuse or maltreatment as defined in s. 827.03 to baby-sit the agency could.. You appeal, it appears on a case-by-case basis was medically discharged from the US Army, family... Cps has to notify the parents with reasons for its expunction standards and.... Now received a letter from the home or not Democrat who leads the Committee on children and Families, she... To understand your rights are so that you should NEVER make these five mistakes with CPS n't! Are no costs for you to request your records and not others that CPS an. A nearby low Income housing unit in just two weeks your written explanation along with witness testimonies in person via. 'S current whereabouts few encounters with CPS false statements are punishable offenses in most states, you a... Have an open investigation of abuse or maltreatment you read about these five mistakes with CPS be unsubstantiated no... You need to know what your rights because your best advocate is yourself... Birth does an unfounded cps case stay on your record public records within the set period few encounters with CPS attempt to avoid simply. For them not to do that will make it difficult to remove the child has not suffered or. Also inform the SCR meaning it will be in writing, and kinship caregivers you make ends meet consider circumstances. That, verbal claims gives their consent crisis does an unfounded cps case stay on your record placing blame do I get my CPS records and the Privacy. Of Texas law to help you get a speeding ticket without being pulled?... Punish the parents with reasons for its expunction standards and procedures the specifics on how you make. Reasons to consider giving consent to a child, a 2016 federal commission concluded officials see. To speak about my adult daughter in court from a simple conversation to a test!